It's impossible--maybe even asinine--to attempt to explain or justify your love for your favorite musical act or artist. It would take me thousands of words to explain my relationship with Pearl Jam, and I do consider it to be a relationship. Witness the band's 2006 VH1
Storytellers episode: Ed tells the story behind the song "Alive" in which a 15 year old boy finds out from his mother that the man he "thought was your daddy, was nothing but a---". That's Ed's story. And, he explains on
Storytellers that, when he wrote the lyrics, the chorus (just the repeated refrain "Oh, I, I'm still alive" ) felt like "a curse." The anger and rage of a teenager coming to grips with a grievous wrong done to him that can never be undone, especially because the real father, a family "friend," had died a few years earlier.
Cut to years later, when "Alive" becomes the break-out hit on PJ's first album and Ed begins to witness the phenomenon of the audience responding to his lyrics. They--WE--took it on as a mantra, an affirmation of our own will to survive. As he watches fans responding to the song, as he hears the audience take his words and sing them back to him, he realizes that the meaning of the words has shifted. And, he explains, "Here's the thing. When you changed the meaning, you lifted the curse."
That's a hint at the connection I feel with "my band." You many not get why I love Pearl Jam so much, but I'm pretty sure most of you understand the sort of connection I'm talking about. At least I hope you can. I can't imagine my life without Pearl Jam in it. I mean that literally. So many of my fondest memories are attached with road trips to PJ shows. So many of my darkest moments have been soothed by Ed's cracked baritone rumbling out of my speakers. To say that I've often grounded myself in this music is an understatement.
We've grown together, Pearl Jam and I. The music reflects that. The one thing you can't accuse PJ of is repeating itself. Each disc stands as a singular statement, not so much encompassing as eclipsing the one that came before it. I remember the first time I heard
Binaural, without a doubt the least accessible of all the discs, I was put off. There was so much pain there, and not the angst-ridden pain of
Ten, but a more resolute sort of pain, an acceptance that the world is just plain fucked-up. I didn't want to face up to that at the time. Then, years later, I'm listening to a Bootleg and the band eases into "Sleight of Hand," a song about a man who wakes up to find himself empty and "wondering about wandering."
"He found himself staring down at his own hands, not remembering the change, not recalling the past."
The aching loneliness of that song hit me like a ton of bricks . It just rang true in a way it had not before. Then I went back to
Binaural and listened again. The disaffection and the pain were still there, but suddenly I understood it. Some imperceptible shift in my own perspective made me respond to it in a new way.
The fact that I can constantly find something new within music I've been listening to for nearly 20 years is enough of a justification for my love of it, in my opinion. And, honestly, I don't really feel the need to justify it. I'm really glad that the masses don't share my passion for Pearl Jam. I love the fact that going to PJ shows feels more like a reunion than a gathering of random strangers.
This brings me, finally, to my main subject. Most of you know--because I didn't let you forget it--that I recently saw EdVed play two back-to-back shows at the Ryman Auditorium in Nashville. The "mother church" of country music, with it's red brick exterior,hard church pews and stained glass windows, is a singular venue. Steeped in history and tradition, a Ryman show is always an occasion, and the artist on stage better damn well know it.
Ed most definitely knew it. He vowed to "channel the spirits" on night one and by night two was talking about the fact that "since we're in church, we might as well sing about god" before launching into "Sometimes" ("...sometimes I walk, sometimes I kneel, sometimes I speak of nothing at all, sometimes I reach to myself, dear God...") and a string of his more esoteric songs.
And if Ed was feeling it, quite a few of us in the audience were swimming in it. Not counting the asshole dudes who kept yelling at Ed to "bust out the UKE" (admittedly Ed CAN rock a ukelele, but come on) and the redneck jerk who shouted "Freebird!" on night one (to which Ed responded, "Get that guy outta here. Kick him out. That song was worn out before I was born and it wasn't even written yet.") and the random girl who wouldn't stop, as Ed put it "screaming like a banshee," MOST of us were there to commune with the spirits along with Ed.
God knows I got some religion. On night one, about halfway through the show, I felt someone press their palm into the center of my back. I turned to see a lovely woman, probably close to my age. She leaned forward and said "I've been going to see Pearl Jam since 1993 and this is the most amazing thing I've ever seen. I haven't been this happy in 15 years!" I smiled and said, "I know, sister, I know."
At the end of the show, after Ed closed out with "Arc," a wordless song in which he sings a series of moans and cries and "ahh-ah-ahhhh's" that overlap and build on each other, I turned to her, both our eyes full of tears and we hugged each other so tightly. The spirit had moved us both that night in exactly the same way. I can only surmise that she could tell from being behind me and witnessing my reactions that I was in the same place she was, causing her to reach out to me. It is a moment I will never forget.
He closed out night 2 with "Arc" as well. And I was on pins and needles all night hoping he would do so. But how could he not? At the Mother Church, with the spirits moving, there was little else he could do. Prior to witnessing it, I would have said that it would be impossible to duplicate "Arc" in a live setting. But Ed settled onto his seat, grabbed a second mic and leaned into that suitcase I'm so fascinated with and turned on what I'm gonna call his "loop machine." He leans in and sings the first "ahh-ah-ahhhh" in his upper tenor range, gets that going on the loop then adds another layer, and another until his baritone vibrates the floor. Soon he is screaming and crying and sighing out layers of yearning and wonder and pain. As in night 1, I was speechless, I was tearful. I was in awe.
I could go on about the setlists: Cat Stevens' "Trouble," best audience sing along's to "...Small Town," "Porch" and "Wishlist" I've ever had the privilege to be a part of, a totally new arrangement of "Betterman" that prevented the audience from taking it over, forcing us to listen and hear it for what felt like the first time. And so on... But the real heart of what I experienced there was the exchange between an artist and his audience, the call-and-response feedback that is at the heart of all the best music. The spirits came down and played with us at the Ryman last week. And I am better for having been there to witness it.
Viva La Rock!